Contemporary home with a shaded teak entrance, white stucco, broad glass living-room windows and a limestone forecourt edged with sea grape and coontie.

Downtown Sarasota's Fall Restaurant Shuffle Kept the Cooks and Changed the Rooms

Anna Caragiulo is 87, and she sewed the 14.5-foot gold curtains that now hang in her family's new dining room on Ringling Boulevard. Her son Paul says they soften the room and improve its acoustics, which matters in a restaurant built around his vinyl collection. Behind the bar are strips of marble the family saved from the old Palm Avenue bar, cut down and set into the new one. The original Italian film posters came along too, as reported in Sarasota Magazine's preview of the new Caragiulos.

That detail sums up downtown Sarasota dining this fall. Between mid-September and the first of November, a long-running restaurant moved, a well-loved one closed and its cottage changed hands, and a third reopened under a new name with the same owners. The cooks you know are mostly still cooking. The rooms changed, and the restaurants that came through it all had found a way to keep control of a room.

The Mira Mar Lease That Ran to 2040

The Caragiulo brothers opened at 69 S. Palm Ave. in 1989. Paul Caragiulo once called it "a meatball hero and Styrofoam cup kind of place." When demolition of the Mira Mar was proposed in 2022, the restaurant's lease ran through 2040. Dr. Mark Kauffmann sold the property to Seaward Development for $17.3 million in 2023 with that lease still in effect. Seaward then won approval to restore the historic Palm Avenue frontage and build two 18-story condominium towers behind it.

Caragiulos closed on Palm Avenue in October 2025 with about 15 years left on that lease. Kauffmann also owns the Ringling Boulevard parcel under the new building, so the family stayed with a landlord they already knew while the old block was redeveloped.

The restaurant opened to the public on Tuesday, Oct. 27, at 1833 Ringling Blvd., nearly a year after its last meal on Palm. Suarez Architecture designed the building. The room is about 4,300 square feet with 150 seats, a full bar and a covered patio. Inside are Murano glass fixtures commissioned in Venice and vintage furniture that was restored in Italy and shipped over in a container.

"It doesn't look like it was just built. It's like a Mastroianni movie from 1968."

Paul Caragiulo, speaking to Sarasota Magazine

The menu works the same way as the room. The old favorites stayed: pasolini at $23, meatballs at $21 and the 37-layer lasagna at $25. New dishes sit above them, including a 40-ounce bone-in bistecca Fiorentina for two at $115 and a 20-ounce veal chop Milanese at $59. Many longtime employees are expected back after working at the family's other restaurants during the closure.

Same Room, New Name at 1660 Main Street

Caragiulos kept its landlord. Ryan Boeve and Mark Baldwin kept their room. Lucile Pizza & Wine Bar closed at 1660 Main St., and the same two owners opened Mitchell's Food and Wine in the space, according to the Herald-Tribune.

The new name comes from family. Mitchell was the surname of Boeve's grandmother, Lucile, and it was his mother's maiden name. Boeve uses it as his middle name, and so does his son Aaron, who is the chef de cuisine. SRQ Daily's Nov. 3 review describes the menu as a return to the classical style longtime diners remember from Boeve's years at Zoria and Pomona.

What's on the plates now:

  • Baked littleneck clams in a cast-iron pan with maître d'hôtel butter and garlic breadcrumbs
  • Blue crab and avocado salad with Old Bay, bonito remoulade and trout roe
  • Duck breast with a dark cherry gastrique and a small potato gratin
  • Short rib brasato with cipollini onion jam
  • Pizza, carried over from Lucile, including a pie with Lion's Mane mushrooms and brie

The small dining room has been redone in a midcentury modern style. Chefs carry plates to the tables themselves. Mitchell's is open 4:30 to 9 p.m. every day.

A Towles Court Cottage Changes Hands

The third change started with a loss. On Sept. 15, chef and owner Steve Phelps announced that Indigenous had closed after 15 years, the Herald-Tribune reported. That closing freed one of downtown's best-known small dining rooms, the cottage at 239 S. Links Ave. in Towles Court.

Elier Rodriguez, the chef and owner of Alma de España, bought the building outright instead of leasing it. According to the Business Observer, Sarasota County property records show the roughly 1,100-square-foot building sold for $1.65 million on Sept. 28 to Cathedral Hospitality Holdings LLC, which state filings register to Rodriguez. For scale, the new Caragiulos fits 150 seats into roughly four times that floor area.

Alma closed its South Osprey Avenue location near Southside Village on Sept. 30. It opened in the cottage on Nov. 1, Hoodline reported, bringing its Spanish tapas and wood-fired grill concept downtown. The menu runs from gazpacho to paella to flan and draws on Spain and on Cuba, where Rodriguez was born and raised. His résumé includes two years at Picasso inside the Bellagio in Las Vegas and kitchens from Le Cirque Las Vegas to The Fontainebleau Miami Beach.

Where to Find Them Now

Restaurant Before Now Who's behind it
Caragiulos 69 S. Palm Ave., Mira Mar, 1989 to Oct. 2025 1833 Ringling Blvd., open since Oct. 27 The Caragiulo family, same landlord
Mitchell's Food and Wine Lucile Pizza & Wine Bar, 1660 Main St. Same address, new name and menu Ryan Boeve and Mark Baldwin
Alma de España South Osprey Ave. near Southside Village, closed Sept. 30 239 S. Links Ave., former Indigenous cottage, open since Nov. 1 Chef-owner Elier Rodriguez, who bought the building

The Rooms That Went to Newcomers

When the people running a room don't stay on, the space goes to someone new.

SaraSocial opened Sept. 15 at 1990 Main St., Suite 112, in the space Fork & Hen used to occupy. Owner Bobby Khush serves Southern coastal food with cocktails, music and hookah on the patio. It is open Tuesday through Sunday and serves until 2 a.m. on Fridays and Saturdays, with the kitchen open until 1:30 a.m., according to Sarasota Magazine.

In the Rosemary District, Artisan Cheese Company closed at 550 Central Ave. in September after 14.5 years under owner Louise Converse. Your Observer reported that the space will go to a restaurant tenant the landlord approved.

Other newcomers have filled the blocks in between. Sorella, a new Italian restaurant, opened at 1532 Main St. Tastes of the Philippines opened at 1987 Ringling Blvd., on the same boulevard as the new Caragiulos. Baldoria also opened downtown, with tapas and plates that start from the Mediterranean and add Italian and Spanish twists, according to the Herald-Tribune's October roundup.

Dinner, Then The Bay

The Bay's free evening calendar pairs well with an early table at any of these downtown rooms. The park's published schedule lists these events, and the park notes that times can change:

  1. Thursday, Nov. 12: an outdoor screening of Top Gun from 1986, 7 to 9 p.m.
  2. Sundays at 4:30 p.m.: free concerts with Clover's Revenge on Nov. 15, J Santi on Nov. 22, and Grace Burke & Gannon Torrella on Nov. 29
  3. Dec. 3 and Dec. 10: The Holiday, then It's a Wonderful Life, both starting at 7 p.m.
  4. Dec. 12: the Holidays at The Bay Community Celebration, 4 to 7:45 p.m.
  5. December Sundays: COVERGIRL Band on Dec. 13, Ace Suggs on Dec. 20, and dueling pianos from The Copper Piano on Dec. 27

The Sunday concerts end at 5:30 p.m., early enough for dinner at Caragiulos or Mitchell's, which serves until 9 p.m.

A downtown address comes with the restaurants around it, and Donna follows those changes as closely as she follows the listings. If you're thinking about how a move would change your own dinner routine, Donna Wrobel is glad to walk you through the blocks around Main, Ringling and Links. Let's Connect.

Work With Us

Etiam non quam lacus suspendisse faucibus interdum. Orci ac auctor augue mauris augue neque. Bibendum at varius vel pharetra. Viverra orci sagittis eu volutpat. Platea dictumst vestibulum rhoncus est pellentesque elit ullamcorper.

Follow Me on Instagram